The Muppets are back, and they're stirring up a mix of fond memories and mischief, according to critics. But is this revival a nostalgic treat or a controversial twist? The Muppet Show's return has sparked a buzz, and it's not just the felt-covered stars that are making headlines.
The 2026 revival features a blend of old and new, with veteran performers like Dave Goelz reprising their iconic roles. Ben Dowell from The Times applauds the show's ability to bridge generations, suggesting it's a gateway for the young to discover the Muppets' magic. He highlights the clever use of slightly edgy humor and a Bridgerton spoof with Miss Piggy, calling it a refreshing return to the show's roots.
A running gag involves Sabrina Carpenter's Manchild singer mimicking Miss Piggy's style, leading to a hilarious legal battle. Dowell appreciates Carpenter's playful participation, awarding the show four stars.
Anita Singh of The Telegraph echoes the sentiment, emphasizing the rare faithfulness to the original. She describes the experience as a joyful, nostalgic journey, earning four stars. Her review also mentions her son's enjoyment, albeit with a touch of randomness.
Rebecca Nicholson, writing for the Financial Times, offers a unique perspective. She believes the show takes a different approach, adding more chaos and a hint of naughtiness while maintaining age-appropriate content. Nicholson's highlights include Beaker's eye-popping experiment and Gonzo's fiery roller-skating, showcasing the show's playful chaos.
Daniel Fienberg from The Hollywood Reporter acknowledges that while it's not the show's peak, it's a welcome return to the Muppets' signature charm. James Poniewozik of The New York Times argues that these Muppets are both a throwback and exactly what we need today. John Nugent, in Empire, praises the revival for avoiding parody and focusing on the core Muppets experience, awarding five stars for its escalating madness.
Kermit's self-deprecating humor hints at the show's potential future. With such positive reviews, it seems the Muppets might be gearing up for a full-scale comeback, their first since 1981. But here's where it gets intriguing: is this revival a nostalgic trip down memory lane, or a bold new take?
The Muppets' return has critics and fans alike buzzing. Will it be a fleeting visit or a grand reunion? Share your thoughts on this controversial question: is the new Muppet Show a nostalgic masterpiece or a daring departure from the original?
